Dear Mr. Applebome:
As a Teaneck resident, the rabbi of the largest Orthodox synagogue in
town, and president of the Rabbinical Council of Bergen County, I read
your article about the alleged divisiveness in the Teaneck community
with great interest but also with a tremendous sense of disappointment.
I was frankly dismayed that you chose to criticize the Orthodox
community for its implicit sins and inadequacies without quoting even
one Orthodox spokesman in this township.
Mayor Katz is not the "mayor of the Orthodox," but the mayor of all
the people. In the most recent election, he was the largest vote getter
among all the candidates, and received overwhelming and wide-ranging
support in every district in Teaneck.
Had you chosen to speak with an Orthodox Jew, instead of merely
quoting our detractors, you might have learned that despite constituting
only 15 percent of the population, Orthodox Jews make up more than 60
percent of the Teaneck Volunteer Ambulance Corps. and pay more than 60
percent of the property taxes.
You would have learned that we walk in the streets on the Sabbath
because 90 percent of the roads in Teaneck do not have sidewalks.
Decent Families
Most of all, you would have learned that we are decent, quiet,
law-abiding middle-class families that almost never attract the
attention of the police; that we have looked the other way as the
township has stocked the public schools with children from other
districts (at our expense); and do not complain when the Board of
Education refuses to hire Orthodox Jews as teachers (and fired existing
Orthodox teachers for their inability to attend the suddenly "mandatory
and indispensable" Saturday morning faculty meetings).
Our stability as neighbors has increased property values across
Teaneck to the advantage of all its residents.
Some Teaneck residents may be nostalgic for the days of the first
voluntary integration and the soul-searching after the Pannell shooting,
but neither event speaks to my historical memory at all. I, like most
other Teaneck residents, did not live here in those years.
Harmony
My own neighbors—on my street—have been blacks and whites, Orthodox
Jews, non-Orthodox Jews, and non-Jews. Who really cares? I serve on the
Teaneck Civilian Complaint Review with people who represent the same
full range of diversity in Teaneck. Who cares?
Our "rising political fortunes" are attributable to what I thought
was called "democracy." We moved here, opened businesses here, and vote
for the candidates of our choice—Orthodox, non-Orthodox, and
non-Jewish—and sometimes our candidates win, and sometimes our
candidates lose. But we trust that whoever wins will govern for the
betterment of our entire community.
Mayor Katz is correct when he says that the issues are political, not
religious. Years of mismanagement has led Teaneck to the point where it
has the least commercial development of any town in our area, and more
parks than any other town in New Jersey. It is the only town with no
commercial development along Route 4, and therefore we suffer from the
highest property taxes in the region.
Discrimination
Our public schools have some of the lowest test scores in the state,
and the second highest per-student cost in the county. We Orthodox pay
through the nose, get almost nothing in return when it comes to
services, and then have to suffer the complaints of others when we wish
to have a voice in the governance of our town.
I need not go on. My point is, you might have uncovered the true
story (the guilt feelings engendered in some non-Orthodox Jews who live
in close proximity to the Orthodox), as you would have learned about the
vital contribution of the Orthodox community to every aspect of civic
life in Teaneck—had you only chosen to actually speak with an Orthodox
Jew.
That you did not is, in my humble opinion, a breach of journalistic
standards and particularly unworthy of the New York Times.